November 20, 2026

Why cyber insurance should never replace cyber security measures

placeholder

Cyber insurance is important, but it shouldn’t replace proactive cyber security programs or risk management strategy as Ekaterina Khrustaleva, COO of application security company ImmuniWeb, explains.

The continuing increase in ransomware attacks globally has greatly influenced the cyber insurance landscape. It is estimated that incidents related to ransomware cost businesses more than $75 billion per year, with that figure anticipated to jump to over $10.5 trillion annually by 2025. Credit ratings agency AM Best reported ransomware now accounts for 75% of all cyber insurance claims.

Recent years have seen a surge in ransomware attacks, with 2021 being a year of some unprecedented high-profile hacks, such as disastrous ransomware attacks against Colonial Pipeline, the largest pipeline system for refined oil products in the US, meat processing company JBS, and IT vendor Kaseya. In the latter ransomware incident, the attack paralyzed as many as 1,500 organizations across the world by compromising Kaseya’s VSA software.

Cybersecurity agencies from the UK, Australia and the US recently issued a joint advisory warning of an increase in sophisticated, high-impact ransomware attacks targeting critical infrastructure organizations globally, including those in emergency services, food and agriculture, government facilities, and information technology sectors. In the wake of highly-publicised attacks, ransomware operators have shifted their focus to mid-sized businesses to avoid scrutiny from law enforcement, which is worrying because not all of these businesses have an effective cyber security program in place or are covered by a cyber insurance policy.

Indeed, more and more companies are turning to cyber insurance to combat security threats, which can help to reduce the impact of a security incident. With the world becoming increasingly reliant on digital forms of data storage and communications, cyber insurance is a fast-growing market. Current estimates suggest that the global cyber insurance market will grow to $28 billion by 2026.

Cyber insurance is designed to protect both individuals and businesses from internet-based risks, such as data breaches, cyber-attacks, ransomware attacks, phishing scams, supply-chain attacks, and other digital threats, as well as losses resulting from damage to IT infrastructure.

How cyber insurance works and what it covers

Typically, cyber insurance comes in two forms: first-party coverage and third-party coverage. First-party coverage is intended to reduce the financial impact on the company that bought the insurance (the insured). It covers security incidents such as the digital threats above, but also cyber extortion demands and compromised business emails suffered by the insured.

Third-party coverage provides liability coverage for companies responsible for a client’s security. In other words, it covers legal expenses that result from a company being accused of causing another firm’s cyber losses.

Although the industry has seen some standardization, there is no common insurance policy that provides full depth of coverage for every security risk and can be utilized by every business. There are many costs related to cyber incidents that cyber insurance policies typically do not cover. These include system upgrades to prevent future incidents, potential future profits that may be lost, decline in revenue/earnings, market share and share price, a decrease of the value of the business in the event of intellectual property theft and reputation damage due to a breach.

The cost of cyber insurance is tied to risk exposure that a business presents, so insurance premiums for cyber coverage vary widely across different industries. According to financial services firm AdvisorSmith, the average cost of cyber insurance for small businesses has risen approximately 7% in 2021 leading to estimated average annual premiums for small businesses of $1,589 for $1 million in cyber liability coverage.

AdvisorSmith confirms that the three sectors paying the highest prices for cyber insurance fall into the finance industry. The ten sectors with the highest annual cyber insurance expenses include payment processing, financial services, investment services, law firms, insurance, pharmaceuticals, gaming, oil and gas, e-commerce, and telecommunications.

A rise in demand has triggered an increase in insurance premiums. 2021 saw some of the largest ransom demands ever. For example, in March, Taiwanese computer manufacturer Acer was hit by a Revil ransomware attack, with hackers demanding $50 million in ransom. JBS USA and Colonial Pipeline also gave in to the ransom demands and paid hackers $11 million and $4.4 million respectively, although in the latter case the FBI was able to retrieve a portion of the money.

Ransomware payments have become such an issue that many cyber insurers are now restricting ransomware payouts. AXA is just one of the major cyber insurers that have halted ransomware crime compensations, for customers in France.

Cyber insurance is not enough to protect your business

The use of cyber insurance to pay ransoms is bad rather than good, as it will likely encourage other would-be victims to regard insurance as a panacea, disregarding their cybersecurity and data protection. Moreover, in light of such an alarming trend, cyber insurance companies will inevitably raise their premiums thereby hurting innocent companies and making insurance far too expensive for others.

While cyber insurance policies can help organizations recover some losses s, they do not reduce cyber risks nor negate the need for implementing proactive cyber security programs in the first place. Besides, many cyber insurers are wary of providing cyber coverage to firms that do not have robust cyber policies against cyber threats.

For instance, US and European insurers operating in the Lloyd’s of London insurance market have started to charge higher premiums, to cover ransoms and repair hacked networks and for business interruption losses. The insurer, which has a fifth of the global cyber market, has also discouraged its 100-odd syndicate members from taking on cyber business in 2022.

A proactive cybersecurity approach

With the constantly evolving cyber threat landscape, it’s crucial for businesses and organizations to establish a proactive cyber security strategy and improve their cyber security posture by focusing on robust, end-to-end protection, thus reducing susceptibility to security incidents (as well as expenses related to cyber insurance).

A proactive cybersecurity approach involves pre-emptive measures that an organization can implement to reduce the risk of cyber exposure and protect itself from potential harm caused by cyber intrusions, data leaks and other threats. Such an approach includes understanding the threats an organization is facing (i.e., types of attacks most common in a particular industry), evaluation of critical assets that must be protected and implementation of proactive cyber security measures (updated anti-malware solutions, perimeter defences, data segmentation, timely software patches and upgrades, web filtering services, etc.).

By combining an efficient cybersecurity program and cyber insurance policies an organization can create a risk management strategy that reduces expenses and improves its risk posture.