Where does forex spread data come from?
When scanning a broker comparison table, the figure that often catches the eye is the spread. The spread is the gap between the price at which a broker will buy a currency pair from a client (the bid) and the price at which it will sell to the client (the ask). It is the dealing cost a client pays on entry and exit, whether or not a separate commission is also charged, and comparison sites rank brokers largely on it.
That single number, however, can come from very different sources. A spread figure might be published by the broker itself, taken from a demo account, or recorded on a funded live account. The three sources are not equivalent. This article looks at what each source reveals and where the data behind broker comparisons originates.
Broker-published figures
A broker-published figure is a number the broker chooses to show. It is often presented as a “from” figure, meaning the lowest spread available under the best conditions. The reader cannot see when it was recorded, on which account type, or how often that level actually occurs.
Because the broker controls the figure, there is no independent way to verify whether it reflects typical trading conditions. A broker may quote a spread that was available for only a few minutes during a quiet period. Without time stamps and account details, the figure is best understood as a marketing benchmark rather than a guaranteed dealing cost.
Demo accounts
A demo account is a simulation. Orders placed on it are not sent to a live market; the broker’s demo system fills them. Brokers commonly run demo accounts on separate systems from live accounts, so the prices, fills and behaviour under fast market conditions on a demo account are not guaranteed to match what a live client sees.
This separation means a spread reading taken on a demo account cannot be treated as proof of what a real trader would pay. While demo accounts are useful for learning platform mechanics, they do not provide the same execution environment as a funded account.
Funded live accounts
A funded live account is an account holding real money at the broker. The quote recorded on it is the one a real client was shown at that moment, on that account type. It therefore reflects actual dealing conditions rather than a simulation or a marketing figure.
Because a demo or broker-published figure cannot be checked against a real client’s experience, an independent test using funded live accounts is the only one of the three sources that a third party can stand behind.
CompareForexBrokers.co.uk records its UK spread readings on funded live accounts at 27 FCA-authorised firms rather than on demo accounts or from broker-supplied figures. The readings are taken at 09:00, 12:00 and 16:00 London time across three trading days, and the site publishes the modal value for each of 41 account configurations, with the account type stated alongside each figure.
CompareForexBrokers.co.uk is a forex and CFD broker comparison site for UK traders. It covers only brokers authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority and ranks them using spread and execution data recorded from funded live accounts rather than figures supplied by the brokers.
Timing and account type
Spreads are not static. They move through the day and widen around news releases. A reading on one broker can only be compared fairly with a reading on another if both were taken at the same clock times on the same days and the account type is stated.
Without consistent timing and a clearly stated account type, a comparison table can mislead. A spread recorded under quieter conditions will not align with one taken during volatile trading, just as readings from different account tiers are not directly comparable. The method behind the data matters as much as the number itself.
Conclusion
Spread figures in broker comparison tables are only as reliable as the data collection method used. Broker-published numbers and demo readings offer limited insight; funded live account data gathered under consistent conditions provides a verifiable basis for comparison. To understand what sits behind a quoted spread, knowing the source of the data is the essential first step.