November 20, 2026

“The Real AI Problem in Marketing is Organisational, not Technical” warns Advertising Production Consultancy Head

Francisco-Lima

The marketing and advertising industry is facing a structural challenge that is quietly undermining not only the promise of AI, but brands’ ability to adopt and unlock the value of emerging technologies. While 99% of UK advertisers are using or engaging with generative AI, only 14% report significant business impact1. The head of production consultancy Amplify, warns the issue is not the technology but the legacy operational models and organisational systems into which it is being deployed.

Francisco Lima, General Manager at Amplify from MurphyCobb, argues the industry has been approaching AI from the wrong angle. “The dominant barrier to AI ROI isn’t technology related. It’s old operating models and organisational systems with AI sprinkled on top,” he says. According to Lima, companies that are attempting to modernise their capabilities while leaving their structures, workflows, and governance models largely untouched won’t be able to benefit from what transformational technologies such as AI are able to deliver.

This misalignment is creating what he describes as a “structural AI stall”. Organisations start pilots, experiment with tools, and announce innovation programmes, but when these collide with legacy workflows, siloed teams, and rigid governance, they fail to scale. “Both agencies and in-house marketing teams are launching all these initiatives and then watching them grind to a halt when they encounter the organisation’s actual operations and how the work flows through it,” Lima explains. “The capability to properly embed AI simply isn’t there.”

According to Lima, governance is no longer simply a best-practice consideration. With the EU AI Act now in force, organisations must also ensure AI systems are deployed within auditable and compliant operating frameworks. “The operating model question and the compliance question are increasingly becoming the same question,” he says.

The challenge is compounded by the increasing prevalence of consolidation. While agency production consolidation was intended to simplify operations, research from Bain & Company2 shows it has often produced the opposite effect: deeper complexity, slower innovation cycles and increased lock‑in across vendors, technology and data. Lima notes that “the results of consolidation have been uneven: creating new layers of complexity as well as   technology, data, and strategy lock‑in across vendors.”

Recent research from BCG3 suggests organisations understand the complexities around AI use but struggle to act on it. More than half of CEOs cite unclear links between AI initiatives and financial outcomes, while only a minority have embedded AI within broader business transformation programmes. According to Lima, this ‘execution gap’ is where most AI value is being lost.

The structural nature of the problem is reinforced further by PwC’s 2026 Global CEO Survey, which identifies resistance to change, skills shortages, and weak governance as the top barriers to AI transformation – none of them being issues with the technology itself. Lima sees this as the clearest signal yet that the industry must shift its focus. “The next competitive advantage won’t come from piling more tools on top of old workflows,” he says. “It will come from redesigning the operating model so people, process, and technology can work in harmony.”

The comments come as MurphyCobb outlines an alternative path for the industry in a new research paper, From ‘Pilot Purgatory’ to the Fluid Network. The paper introduces the Fluid Network, MurphyCobb’s modular, vendor-neutral operating model designed to help brands orchestrate the right talent, technology, data and AI capabilities around evolving business needs, with the brand at the centre. In doing so, brands gain the freedom and confidence to assemble the right capabilities around each brief, campaign or moment. This enables them to protect quality from idea through to execution, create content with meaning and relevance, and move at the speed of culture with fresh, personalised omnichannel content that responds to changing needs, resonates with key audiences and performs at scale. The research paper From ‘Pilot Purgatory’ to the Fluid Network can be downloaded and read in full HERE.