Young shoppers three times more likely to abandon retailers over poor loyalty schemes, research reveals
Younger shoppers are the most likely to abandon a retailer over its loyalty scheme, despite feeling more loyal to retailers than they did three years ago, according to new research from HyperFinity, the AI-powered actionable intelligence company.
The research found that 61% of under-35s feel more loyal to retailers than they did three years ago, yet 28% have stopped shopping with a retailer because of its loyalty programme. This is compared with just 10% of over-65s.
The findings are released alongside HyperFinity’s Retail Loyalty Index Pulse report, produced with Bloomreach and Eagle Eye. The survey covered 2,000 UK consumers who belonged to at least one of the 51 loyalty programmes featured in the March 2026 Retail Loyalty Index.
Thomas Hill, co-founder of HyperFinity, said: “Younger shoppers may feel more loyal to retailers, but that loyalty cannot be taken for granted. A scheme that offers generic rewards or fails to deliver on its promises can quickly undermine that relationship. There is no one-size-fits-all approach to loyalty – retailers need to understand what individual customers value and make sure the benefits they offer are relevant, worthwhile and deliverable.”
That challenge extends to personalisation. Although shoppers may expect offers to reflect their interests, they do not necessarily see the technology behind them as a benefit in itself. The report found that 69% are comfortable with AI being used to deliver more relevant deals, but just 4.4% identified AI-powered recommendations as a retail trend they most want to see.
“Personalisation is becoming an expectation rather than a reward in itself,” Thomas added. “Customers aren’t concerned about the technology behind an offer; they want offers that are relevant, useful and worth acting on. AI can help retailers deliver that, but only if it improves the customer experience.”
The report also highlights the importance of value. While 44% of shoppers say they would stay loyal to a retailer through rising household costs if the rewards were worthwhile, lower-income households are more likely to prioritise switching to a cheaper retailer. For loyalty schemes to retain customers, the value they promise must be meaningful as well as relevant.
Download a copy of HyperFinity’s Retail Loyalty Index Pulse report here.