Lawyer urges businesses to ask tougher questions about AI use as courts draw clear line on liability
David Bailey
‘AI is a tool not a defence’
Businesses using professional advisers should take a closer interest in how artificial intelligence is being used after a series of court decisions and regulatory interventions confirmed that responsibility for advice cannot simply be passed on to AI systems.
In a new analysis of developments over the past two years, a partner at law firm DMH Stallard warns that while AI is now embedded across many professional services, courts and regulators have consistently held individuals and organisations accountable when AI-generated material proves inaccurate, misleading or entirely fabricated.
A growing body of case law has reinforced a straightforward principle that those providing professional advice remain responsible for checking and validating the accuracy of AI-generated content. Recent cases have seen lawyers sanctioned for relying on fictitious legal authorities generated by AI systems, while experts have come under judicial criticism for allowing AI-generated conclusions to influence reports presented to the court.
David Bailey, Partner at DMH Stallard, said:
“When AI first entered mainstream professional practice, one of the biggest unanswered questions was who would be responsible when something went wrong. We now have a much clearer picture.
“The courts and regulators have been remarkably consistent. If a professional chooses to use AI, they remain responsible for the quality, accuracy and reliability of the advice they provide. AI is a tool, not a defence.
“What is perhaps less well understood is the growing risk around confidentiality and privilege. Businesses need to think carefully before uploading documents, legal advice or sensitive information into publicly available AI tools, because that information may not enjoy the protections many people assume it does.”
The Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) has also issued a warning notice making it clear that the use of AI does not reduce, remove or transfer a solicitor’s professional responsibilities.
DMH Stallard is encouraging organisations to have more transparent conversations with professional advisers about how AI is being used, what safeguards are in place and whether confidential information is being entered into public systems.
The firm advises businesses to:
- Ask advisers how AI is being used and what human checks are undertaken.
- Understand who remains responsible for work produced with AI assistance.
- Be aware of the limitations and risks of individual AI tools.
- Keep pace with rapidly evolving AI regulation and guidance.
- Consider their own liability when deploying AI-driven customer services or communications.
- Think carefully before uploading confidential or legally sensitive information to public AI platforms.
David added:
“The answer to the question of who pays when AI gets it wrong has turned out to be reassuringly traditional, usually the professional who was engaged to provide the advice.
“The challenge now is ensuring organisations reap the benefits of AI without creating new legal and commercial risks in the process.”