November 20, 2026

Black Friday fraud warning for retailers, as one in four shoppers admits returning a different item

Samir_Kamnani_Senior-International-Programme-Manager_Loop-Returns_reduced
A global study into shopper and retailer behaviours has found that one in every four (26%) UK online shoppers admits to sending back something other than the original item when making a return. The new research, from ecommerce operations platform Loop, was conducted independently among over 1,000 UK consumers and 200 UK retail decision-makers, and revealed how everyday shoppers are exploiting returns, from swapping
items to concealing clothing that has already been worn.

Within the UK consumer findings, almost a third (31%) say they sometimes or often give a reason that differs from the truth to help secure a refund or exchange. Meanwhile, 14% say they have returned clothing after wearing it briefly but selected a different reason for the return.

With the lead up to peak season shopping only a few weeks away, 82% of UK retailers say returns fraud and abuse is a problem for their business.
Missing parcels, swapped products and “wear and return”

The industry data reveals that retailers report returns challenges extending well beyond unwanted purchases. False claims that goods have not arrived or are damaged are the most commonly encountered form of returns fraud and abuse, cited by 58% of UK retailers surveyed.

Two in five (41%) commonly encounter customers returning different or damaged items, while a third (33%) report “wardrobing”, the term for wearing clothing and then returning it.

The findings emerge as retailers prepare for another fiercely competitive Black Friday and Cyber Monday. IMRG’s review of the 2025 eight-day Black Friday trading period recorded a 1.2% year-on-year fall in UK online retail revenue, with clothing retailers down 7.3%. Alongside this, and according to the Office for National Statistics (ONS), retail sales volumes fell by 0.4% this September compared with the previous month, significantly exceeding economists’
forecasts of a 0.1% decline.Loop warns retailers that protecting the value of each sale deserves as much attention as winning the order.

Samir Kamnani, Senior International Programme Manager at Loop, said: “Black Friday and Christmas sales figures only tell half the story. A sale that looks like a win at checkout can become a loss if a dishonest refund claim goes through or the wrong item comes back to the warehouse. As it does every year, the peak shopping period will trigger a surge in returns, so retailers face the challenge of identifying fraudulent claims without slowing down refunds for genuine customers. Increasingly, technology is being used to assess the risk of individual returns, flagging suspicious activity and delaying refunds in higher-risk cases until items have been received and inspected, while allowing legitimate returns to be processed as normal. However, treating every customer with suspicion is not the answer. Retailers need to identify abuse while keeping returns easy for honest shoppers. Otherwise, they risk losing both the money and the customer.”

Retailers face a balancing act with returns policies

More than half of UK retailers surveyed (56%) use manual reviews to combat returns fraud and abuse, while 29% use return fees and 27% impose customer restrictions. Yet tougher policies carry their own commercial risk. More than half of UK shoppers surveyed (55%) say they have either stopped shopping with an online fashion brand or abandoned a purchase because of its returns policy.

With Black Friday set to trigger a surge in returns, retailers face the challenge of identifying fraudulent claims without slowing down refunds for genuine customers. Increasingly, technology is being used to assess the risk of individual returns, flagging suspicious activity and delaying refunds in higher-risk cases until items have been received and inspected, while allowing legitimate returns to be processed as normal.

.ENDS.

Methodology:
The independent research was conducted online by Sapio Research on behalf of Loop. The study surveyed 1,000 UK consumers who had made an online return in the previous six months and 200 UK retail decision-makers
responsible for ecommerce returns strategies.

*Loop applied the 87% of consumers who told us (via our Sapio-commissioned survey) they would take an exchange under the right conditions, to the actual refund in pounds Loop merchants issued over the past 12 months in each region, showing how much of what’s currently paid out as cash refunds, could instead stay in the merchant’s business as retained revenue.
About Loop:
Loop is an operations platform built for retention. We drive customer confidence across the full shopper journey. Before purchase, Loop reduces hesitation; after purchase, it makes everything that follows predictable—from tracking and returns to exchanges, protection, and support. Trusted by more than 5,000 of the world’s most-loved brands, Loop has processed over 100 million returns and counting. Through innovative features like Workflows, Instant Exchanges, Shop Now, Checkout+, and Bonus Credit, Loop helps brands unlock cost savings, increase customer lifetime value, and retain more revenue. Learn more at loopreturns.com