Workers passed over for promotion reconsidered after AI review, study suggests
HiBob, the company behind Bob, the HR platform helping businesses adapt to the age of AI, today releases new research revealing how AI is giving HR a second opinion on decisions that shape employees’ pay and careers.
AI is now informing some of the most consequential decisions in the workplace, from pay rises (50%) and promotions (51%) to performance ratings (64%) and redundancies (42%).
Crucially, the findings suggest AI is working in employees’ favour. More than half (57%) of HR professionals using AI to review people decisions say it has prompted them to reconsider an employee initially passed over for promotion, while 43% report a more favourable final decision on pay rises and 40% on promotions following an AI-informed review.
A second opinion can challenge the boss
That willingness to take another look extends to managers’ judgements. Almost three-quarters (73%) say they have used AI information to challenge a manager’s proposed people decision, including 42% who did so because an employee’s or candidate’s skills or potential had been overlooked.
The findings suggest AI is giving HR professionals the Organisational Intelligence needed to question managers’ assessments and identify talent that might otherwise be missed.
Recruitment and performance reviews are also seeing different outcomes. Among those using AI to review these decisions, 40% report a more favourable outcome for a candidate’s progression through recruitment or job offer, while 42% report the same for employee performance ratings.
Ronni Zehavi, CEO and Co-Founder of HiBob, comments, “AI is here to stay, and it’s changing how businesses operate. But this isn’t just about technology. It’s about making better decisions. If AI can help HR challenge a manager’s assumptions and recognise talent that might otherwise be overlooked, that’s a huge opportunity.
“This is where organisational intelligence comes in. By connecting information about people, skills and performance, we can understand the bigger picture and make smarter decisions. HR leaders have an opportunity to lead this transformation, not simply react to it.”
Putting AI to work, with checks in place
Beyond individual career decisions, HR professionals are using AI to analyse workforce information (47%), screen candidates or review hiring recommendations (45%) and prepare or review performance assessments (40%). Almost a third (31%) have used it to plan changes to jobs, skills or how work is organised.
Adoption varies across HR functions, however, with more than a third of teams not currently using AI information for pay-rise recommendations (38%) or promotions (33%), while 39% do not use it for grievances or disciplinary matters.
As AI becomes part of these decisions, HR teams are also putting checks in place. The majority (59%) say AI information is checked for accuracy and relevance, while 45% review proposed decisions for unfair or inconsistent treatment and 41% consider individual circumstances that AI may have missed.
Looking to the Horizons
The findings come ahead of Horizons by HiBob, the company’s inaugural flagship event in London on 18 November.
The event will bring together business and HR leaders to explore the future of work. Discussions will cover the rise of AI agents and how organisational intelligence can help businesses make smarter workforce decisions, adapt and grow.
For more information, visit https://events.hibob.com/horizons2026.
Image source: Magnific