November 20, 2026

Companies struggling to prove impact of social impact initiatives as scrutiny rises, major ESG study reveals 

business-analytics-dashboard_2_20

Businesses are reporting widespread social impact activity but struggling to demonstrate what difference it makes, according to Thrive, the social impact measurement platform. 

A new report, The Measurement Gap, analysing 900 ESG reports from 840 companies across seven global markets, found a significant disconnect between the social initiatives businesses undertake and the evidence they provide of their effectiveness. While 74% of companies report community investment and philanthropy activities and 73% discuss employee wellbeing initiatives, the metrics they disclose overwhelmingly capture activity rather than results. 

Across all seven markets, social measurement maturity averaged just 1.5 to 1.9 on a scale of 0 to 4. The UK scored just 1.8 out of four, behind the US and Europe (both 1.9), but ahead of Australia (1.7), Asia (1.6) and India (1.5).  

Broadly, the results reflect a lack of consistent evidence that businesses can use to assess the effectiveness of their initiatives and justify future investment. 

Measurement covers a fraction of activity 

The report found that seven in ten (70%) companies talk about employee engagement, but fewer than one in three (32%) publish an engagement score. Similarly, nearly three-quarters of companies (73%) discuss employee wellbeing within their ESG reports, but just 3% disclose data on absenteeism.  

Both findings point to what Thrive labels a ‘measurement gap’, where companies report widespread social impact activity but struggle to quantify what difference it makes. 

Even the most widely reported social metrics offer limited evidence of impact. Of the ten most commonly disclosed measures, not one captures change attributable to a social programme. Instead, businesses most frequently report employee headcount (685 out of 840 companies), community investment and charitable donations (528), and employee training hours or investment (467) – figures that demonstrate the scale of activity rather than the results it delivers. 

Why closing the measurement gap matters 

The research found that leaving the measurement gap unaddressed can have serious consequences for businesses. Among the 200 UK companies analysed, 67% cited attracting and retaining employees as a reason for social investment – far ahead of risk management (28%), brand reputation (22%) and customer retention (20%). But without evidence of changes in retention, engagement or absenteeism, companies cannot demonstrate whether those investments are paying off. 

A lack of comparable data is also giving business leaders an incomplete picture of performance. For example, the analysis found that volunteering initiatives are frequently assessed in hours, donations in pounds and training in headcounts, making it difficult to compare programmes effectively. In turn, businesses cannot defend social investment when budgets are reviewed or demonstrate its value to boards and investors. 

Benjamin Fellowes, Co-Founder and Chief Product & Strategy Officer at Thrive, said: “Our research shows that the problem isn’t a lack of social initiatives; companies are doing great work. Rather, it’s a lack of evidence about the difference they’re making. That should reassure business leaders, because it doesn’t mean they need to start from scratch or launch more programmes to make progress. The priority now is to measure existing activity more consistently, so organisations can understand what’s working and where they can have the greatest impact.” 

The benefits of better measurement are demonstrable. Construction specialist VolkerLaser, part of VolkerWessels UK, has reported 20% higher bid scores after strengthening its approach to social impact, while recording £48.1 million in social impact in 2023 against a target of £28.5 million. Global engineering and construction company Laing O’Rourke, meanwhile, has been able to demonstrate additional social impact equivalent to 11% of client spend on a project. 

For details on the five practical steps businesses can take to close the measurement gap and better demonstrate the value of their social impact, read The Measurement Gap in full here. 

Image source: magnific