November 21, 2026

Navigating Copyright and Copyright Infringement in The World of AI

placeholder

The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) in recent years has raised new challenges for copyright law, forcing it to adapt to evolving technological landscapes.

The ability of individuals and businesses (‘users’) to prompt AI systems, such as DALL-E by OpenAI, to generate artwork has sparked significant debate, particularly regarding the potential for copyright infringement of existing artistic works.

On 13th January 2025, Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, made a speech showcasing the UK Government’s AI Opportunities Action Plan. Containing 50 recommendations for the Government to implement, the plan aims to align innovation with regulatory frameworks and highlights the need for legal structures to address these emerging concerns.

Myerson Solicitor’s Dispute Resolution Lawyers explore the complexities of copyright law in the context of AI, providing insights into authorship, infringement, and the evolving legal landscape.

AI and Authorship

In the UK, intellectual property law, including copyright law, is governed by the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act (CDPA) 1988. Section 9(3) of the CDPA outlines provisions that could include AI-generated art under its scope. Specifically, it states, “In the case of…artistic work, which is computer generated, the author shall be taken to be the person by whom the arrangements necessary for the creation of the work are undertaken“.

The concept of ‘prompting’ AI systems to generate results based on a user’s request complicates the situation under section 9(3) of the CDPA. It raises questions about who is genuinely responsible for the creation of the work, given that AI systems operate based on user input, which may be interpreted as guiding or controlling the creation process.

Because the CDPA does not recognise joint authorship between humans and AI, the extent of user involvement—specifically the level of prompting—will likely determine who owns the copyright in the resulting work.

However, there remains uncertainty regarding whether the intellectual effort exerted by the user through prompting or their use of AI-generated content as inspiration for further creation will satisfy the “personal touch” requirement for copyright protection.

As the legal landscape is still evolving, users need to keep detailed records of prompts given to AI and any subsequent modifications to the AI-generated output, such as edits using image manipulation software. These records could be crucial in resolving future copyright disputes, which may be decided on a case-by-case basis.

The UK Government’s December 2024 consultation, part of the AI Opportunities Action Plan, aims to clarify these issues and ensure that legal frameworks are in place to support innovation while providing clear guidance to developers and users involved with AI-generated content.

The Application of Existing Copyright Infringement Law to AI

Infringement through Training the AI System

One of the first areas where AI raises potential copyright issues is in the large-scale data scraping required to train AI systems.

Copyright infringement typically involves the unauthorised use or copying of all or substantial portions of copyrighted works without permission.

In the AI context, a notable example is the Getty Images (US) v Stability AI Ltd [2023] EWHC 3090 (Ch) case, in which Getty Images alleged that their works were included in the data used to train Stability AI’s model without their consent.

Although this case is still pending, it highlights the potential liability for AI developers.

By providing sufficiently specific prompts, users could generate images that included elements from Getty Images’ copyrighted works, such as logos, raising concerns about copyright infringement.

The Government has highlighted the importance of ensuring that AI systems adhere to ethical standards, including transparency in sourcing training data.

The AI Opportunities Action Plan stresses that a trustworthy AI ecosystem depends on the ethical and transparent collection of data used in the development of AI models.

Infringement by the User

The question of copyright infringement by users who prompt AI systems is equally complex and remains largely untested in court.

Users familiar with specific artists’ styles and using AI to create works that mimic these styles face potential legal risks. This, similar to the issue of authorship, is currently unclear from a legal standpoint.

As the legal framework evolves, users are encouraged to document every prompt they enter into AI systems. This record could be important if a copyright infringement case arises, helping to establish the user’s effort and creative and intellectual input on the work that is generated with assistance from AI technology.

This approach aligns with the UK Government’s ongoing efforts to promote responsible AI usage and foster public trust in AI, which will require promoting and enforcing ethical practices through clear, transparent regulations for individuals and organisations.

Shaping the Future of AI and Copyright: A Call for Clarity and Collaboration

Given the rapid advancements in AI, particularly in the generation of creative works, the UK Government announced an open consultation in December 2024.

The consultation aims to address the issues, challenges and opportunities presented by AI and copyright law including (amongst other things) the copyright implications of AI-generated outputs (AI-assisted works; entrepreneurial works; and computer-generated works) and how UK copyright law might be reformed to provide greater clarity for users and providers of AI tools.

The outcome of the consultation is awaited with interest.

Navigating the complexities of AI and copyright law can be daunting.

For tailored guidance and expert advice regarding Copyright Disputes or how to protect your Intellectual Property, contact Myerson Solicitors’ Dispute Resolution and Intellectual Property Teams today. Our team is ready to support you in confidently navigating this rapidly developing legal environment.